News Honors Case Summaries

Archives: Deborah Hankinson

 

Dallas Lawyer Deborah Hankinson Among Benchmark Litigation’s Top Texas Appellate Attorneys

Former Texas Supreme Court justice named Local Litigation Star DALLAS – Widely respected Dallas lawyer Deborah Hankinson has earned recognition in Benchmark Litigation as a Local Litigation Star among Texas appellate attorneys. It is the second time the former Texas Supreme Court justice has been… + read more

Attorney:

Former Texas Supreme Court justice named Local Litigation Star

DALLAS – Widely respected Dallas lawyer Deborah Hankinson has earned recognition in Benchmark Litigation as a Local Litigation Star among Texas appellate attorneys. It is the second time the former Texas Supreme Court justice has been selected for this prestigious honor.

Produced by London-based Legal Media Group, Benchmark Litigation is the only publication to focus exclusively on U.S. litigators and litigation-focused law firms. Attorneys undergo rigorous screening by the publication’s editorial team. The team also conducts extensive face-to-face interviews with judges, leading appellate lawyers and general counsel of Fortune 500 companies to make its final selections.

For more information about Ms. Hankinson’s work, please visit http://hankinsonlaw.com/our-team/deborah-hankinson/.

Benchmark Litigation is just the latest honor earned in 2016 by Ms. Hankinson. In recognition of her mediation, arbitration and appellate work, earlier this year she also was named to:

  • The Texas Super Lawyers list of the state’s top legal practitioners for a 14th consecutive year.
  • The Best Lawyers in America for 2017. Best Lawyers is among the oldest and most respected legal guides based in the United States.
  • Texas Lawyer Lifetime Achievement Award in recognition of her tenure on the Texas Supreme Court and for her role in the establishment of the Texas Access to Justice Commission.
  • The National Law Journal’s inaugural ADR Champions listing, recognizing the top 48 alternative dispute resolution trailblazers from across the nation.
  • D Magazine’s Best Lawyers in Dallas for an 11th time.

Hankinson LLP, the pre-eminent civil appellate firm in the Southwest, provides clients with innovative legal insights and judicial perspective in all phases of litigation. The firm’s attorneys work with trial teams to develop strategies designed to put a case in the best position before, during and after trial. Dallas-based Hankinson LLP represents national clients, regional companies, governmental bodies and individuals with trial and appellate matters, and offers mediation and arbitration services as well. Learn more about the firm at http://hankinsonlaw.com.

Attorney:

 

Dallas Attorney Deborah Hankinson Earns Texas Lawyer Lifetime Achievement Award

Former Texas Supreme Court justice recognized for legal aid program for the poor DALLAS – Widely respected Dallas lawyer Deborah Hankinson has earned a Lifetime Achievement Award from the editors of Texas Lawyer in recognition of her career as a Texas Supreme Court justice and… + read more

Attorney:

Former Texas Supreme Court justice recognized for legal aid program for the poor

DALLAS – Widely respected Dallas lawyer Deborah Hankinson has earned a Lifetime Achievement Award from the editors of Texas Lawyer in recognition of her career as a Texas Supreme Court justice and her instrumental role in providing legal aid to low-income Texans.

Now focused on alternative dispute resolution and appellate work, Ms. Hankinson was among the attorneys selected in 2016 who have made an indelible mark on the Texas legal profession. Ms. Hankinson served on the Texas 5th District Court of Appeals in Dallas, followed by the Texas Supreme Court, where she served from 1997-2002. While on the state’s highest court, she helped establish the Texas Access to Justice Commission, which has enabled thousands of low-income Texans to obtain legal aid in civil matters.

Since re-entering private practice in 2003, Ms. Hankinson has solidified her position as one of the state’s leading appellate lawyers as well as one of the most sought-after arbitrators and mediators in the country.

For more information about Ms. Hankinson’s work, please visit http://hankinsonlaw.com/our-team/deborah-hankinson/.

Ms. Hankinson and the other honorees will be recognized at a Sept. 13 awards ceremony at the Belo Mansion in Dallas. She and all the attorneys selected to the 2016 Professional Excellence Award: Lifetime Achievers list are profiled in the September issue of Texas Lawyer at http://www.texaslawyer.com.

Among one of the most honored appellate attorneys in Texas, Ms. Hankinson previously has been recognized by Texas Lawyer in its 2007 Go-To Guide and as one of its Winning Women in 2011. Earlier this year, she was selected to The National Law Journal’s inaugural ADR Champions listing, recognizing the top 48 alternative dispute resolution trailblazers from across the nation.

Hankinson LLP, the pre-eminent civil appellate firm in the Southwest, provides clients with innovative legal insights and judicial perspective in all phases of litigation. The firm’s attorneys work with trial teams to develop strategies designed to put a case in the best position before, during and after trial. Dallas-based Hankinson LLP represents national clients, regional companies, governmental bodies and individuals with trial and appellate matters, and offers mediation and arbitration services as well. Learn more about the firm at http://hankinsonlaw.com.

Attorney:

 

Dallas Attorney Deborah Hankinson Earns Selection to College of Commercial Arbitrators

Accomplished lawyer selected based on arbitration experience, peer recognition DALLAS – Noted Dallas arbitrator, mediator and appellate attorney Deborah Hankinson of Hankinson LLP has been selected as a fellow of the prestigious College of Commercial Arbitrators (CCA). Established to promote the highest standards of conduct,… + read more

Accomplished lawyer selected based on arbitration experience, peer recognition

DALLAS – Noted Dallas arbitrator, mediator and appellate attorney Deborah Hankinson of Hankinson LLP has been selected as a fellow of the prestigious College of Commercial Arbitrators (CCA).

Established to promote the highest standards of conduct, professionalism and ethical practices for commercial arbitrators, CCA membership is by invitation only. Selection criteria include substantial arbitration experience, and fellows must be held in high regard by their peers and those who use commercial arbitration.

A former Texas Supreme Court justice, Ms. Hankinson is among the state’s most respected alternative dispute resolution attorneys. She is a fellow of the American Academy of Appellate Lawyers and sits on the Board of Directors of the American Arbitration Association, where she assists in the development of initiatives, strategies and policy matters. She also is a frequent speaker on ADR topics nationwide and has co-developed continuing education courses for arbitrators addressing issues ranging from decision-making skills to managing the arbitration process.

For more information about Ms. Hankinson’s work, please visit http://hankinsonlaw.com/our-team/deborah-hankinson/.

Earlier this year, Ms. Hankinson was selected to The National Law Journal’s inaugural ADR Champions listing, which recognized the 48 top alternative dispute resolution trailblazers from across the nation. She also has been recognized among the top ADR attorneys by Texas Super Lawyers, which honored her as one of the state’s Top 3 attorneys in the state. She is listed in The Best Lawyers in America for her work in arbitration and mediation, as well as appellate law.   http://www.bizjournals.com/dallas/potmsearch/reprint/submission/6004412

 

Deborah Hankinson Named to Best Lawyers in Dallas List for 2016

D Magazine again honors attorney for appellate, mediation, arbitration practice DALLAS – Noted Dallas appellate lawyer and strategist Deborah Hankinson of Hankinson LLP has earned recognition on D Magazine’s 2016 listing of the Best Lawyers in Dallas. This is the 11th time the former Texas… + read more

Attorney:

D Magazine again honors attorney for appellate, mediation, arbitration practice

DALLAS – Noted Dallas appellate lawyer and strategist Deborah Hankinson of Hankinson LLP has earned recognition on D Magazine’s 2016 listing of the Best Lawyers in Dallas. This is the 11th time the former Texas Supreme Court justice has been recognized in the annual list based on her expertise in appellate law, arbitration, mediation and trial consulting.

Earlier this year, Ms. Hankinson was one of just 48 attorneys nationwide selected to The National Law Journal’s inaugural ADR Champions listing, which honored the leaders and trailblazers in alternative dispute resolution. Last year, Ms. Hankinson was named a Texas Trial Legend by the Dallas Bar Association. She also has earned honors for her work from The Best Lawyers in America, Chambers USA, Texas Super Lawyers, Benchmark Appellate, Texas Lawyer, Dallas Business Journal, Martindale-Hubbell and Lawdragon.

Among the most respected attorneys in Texas, she has been honored by such organizations as the Women’s Advocacy Project, Legal Aid of NorthWest Texas, Texas Equal Access to Justice Foundation, American Board of Trial Advocates, Southern Methodist University Dedman School of Law and the State Bar of Texas.

Ms. Hankinson is Board Certified in Civil Appellate Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization and is a fellow of the American Academy of Appellate Lawyers. She serves on the Board of Directors for the American Arbitration Association.

For more information about her work, please visit http://hankinsonlaw.com/our-team/deborah-hankinson/.

D Magazine’s 2016 listing of the city’s top attorneys was determined through peer nominations submitted by thousands of attorneys throughout North Texas. An independent panel of distinguished lawyers helped the magazine’s editors select the honorees. The complete listing is featured in the May 2016 edition of D Magazine and online at www.dmagazine.com.

Attorney:

 

Deborah Hankinson – Dallas Opera, Board of Directors

On January 21, 2016, Deborah Hankinson was elected to serve a three-year term on the Board of Directors for the Dallas Opera. Attorney: Deborah Hankinson

Attorney:

On January 21, 2016, Deborah Hankinson was elected to serve a three-year term on the Board of Directors for the Dallas Opera.

Attorney:

 

Texas Supreme Court Eliminates $9.6 Million Judgment for Injured Worker Based on the Absence of a Duty

In a highly watched case regarding the duties owed by former property owners, Deborah Hankinson, Brett Kutnick, Rick Thompson, and Jennifer Stagen successfully represented Occidental Chemical Corporation and persuaded the Texas Supreme Court to reverse a $9.6 million negligence judgment awarded to a worker who… + read more

In a highly watched case regarding the duties owed by former property owners, Deborah Hankinson, Brett Kutnick, Rick Thompson, and Jennifer Stagen successfully represented Occidental Chemical Corporation and persuaded the Texas Supreme Court to reverse a $9.6 million negligence judgment awarded to a worker who was partially blinded by acid at a chemical plant years after Occidental’s sale of the plant. Specifically, the Supreme Court addressed whether a property owner who allegedly creates a dangerous condition owes a duty in premises liability to warn of the dangerous condition or to make it safe and a duty in negligence to use reasonable care not to create the dangerous condition in the first place. In answering that question in the negative, the Court rejected the notion that a property owner acts as both owner and independent contractor when improving its own property, subjecting itself to either premises-liability or ordinary-negligence principles depending on the injured party’s pleadings. Instead, the Court held that premises-liability principles apply to a property owner who creates a dangerous condition on its property, and that the claim of a person injured by the condition remains a premises-liability claim as to the owner-creator, regardless of how the injured party chooses to plead it. Because Occidental sold the property eight years before the plaintiff’s accident, the Supreme Court held that Occidental owed no duty of care as that duty had passed to its vendee. The Court therefore reversed the court of appeals’ judgment and rendered judgment that the plaintiff take nothing. See Occidental Chemical Corp. v. Jenkins, No. 13-0961, 2016 WL 82662 (Tex. Jan. 8, 2016).

 

Dallas’ Deborah Hankinson Ranked Among Top 3 Attorneys in Texas

Law partner Rick Thompson also named to 2015 Texas Super Lawyers list   Acclaimed appellate attorney, mediator and arbitrator Deborah Hankinson, founder of leading appellate boutique Hankinson LLP, has been named one of the Top 3 attorneys in Texas based on nominations from fellow lawyers… + read more

Law partner Rick Thompson also named to 2015 Texas Super Lawyers list

 

Acclaimed appellate attorney, mediator and arbitrator Deborah Hankinson, founder of leading appellate boutique Hankinson LLP, has been named one of the Top 3 attorneys in Texas based on nominations from fellow lawyers in the 2015 edition of Texas Super Lawyers, which recognizes the state’s top legal practitioners.

In addition to the Top 3 ranking, Ms. Hankinson earned her fourth selection among the state’s Top 10 lawyers in the exclusive annual listing based on her work in appellate law. Joining her on the Super Lawyers list this year is firm partner Rick Thompson, who earned his second selection to the list for his representation of clients in appellate cases.

Owned by the news publisher Thomson Reuters, Super Lawyers develops its lists based on nominations from lawyers, assessments by a research team, and final evaluations from lawyers in the same practice areas.

Super Lawyers is an important honor because it relies on input from attorneys just like us,” Mr. Thompson says. “It’s gratifying to know that people who do the same legal work view us as among the best.”

Mr. Thompson, a former Texas Assistant Solicitor General, argued and prevailed in the IT-Davy case involving issues of sovereign immunity before the Supreme Court of Texas. He also played a key role in last year’s decision in Bostic v. Georgia-Pacific, a significant asbestos ruling in which the state’s high court found in favor of his client, Georgia-Pacific.

A former Texas Supreme Court justice and widely respected appellate lawyer and strategist, Ms. Hankinson also mediates disputes and serves as an arbitrator. She is a member of the Board of Directors of the American Arbitration Association.

 

Deborah Hankinson Named to The Best Lawyers in America List

Former Texas Supreme Court Justice recognized for work in mediation, arbitration   Prominent Dallas attorney Deborah Hankinson has been selected to The Best Lawyers in America list for the ninth consecutive year for her appellate work and for the first time for her mediation and… + read more

Former Texas Supreme Court Justice recognized for work in mediation, arbitration

 

Prominent Dallas attorney Deborah Hankinson has been selected to The Best Lawyers in America list for the ninth consecutive year for her appellate work and for the first time for her mediation and arbitration work.

The founder of Hankinson LLP, Ms. Hankinson is a former Justice of the Texas Supreme Court and the Texas Fifth Court of Appeals in Dallas. She has earned selection to Best Lawyers since 2008 and is especially pleased to be honored for a wider area of practice.

“For a while now, I’ve been putting more and more time into my mediation and arbitration practice, so it’s nice to be recognized for achievement in that area,” Ms. Hankinson says. “These kinds of tools, along with the ability to resolve disputes even before a lawsuit is filed, can provide individuals and companies with a more effective means of moving conflicts toward solutions.”

Ms. Hankinson, who sits on the Board of Directors and the Executive Committee of the American Arbitration Association, often serves as a neutral in arbitration proceedings, and she is a sought-after mediator in sophisticated business disputes, complex torts and sensitive employment cases.

She is Board Certified in Civil Appellate Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization, a Fellow of the American Academy of Appellate Lawyers and a member of the American Law Institute. In 2014, she served as a faculty member for the College of New Judges, providing training for newly elected judges in Texas.

In 2012, she was honored by Best Lawyers as the Dallas Appellate Lawyer of the Year, and she consistently has earned top-lawyer honors from Chambers USA and Texas Super Lawyers.

 

Dallas’ Deborah Hankinson Selected to Lawdragon 500 Leading Lawyers in America

Noted Dallas appellate attorney, mediator and arbitrator Deborah Hankinson has been selected to the 2014-2015 listing of the Lawdragon 500 Leading Lawyers in America. This is the third Lawdragon 500 selection for Ms. Hankinson, the founder of the Dallas appellate law boutique Hankinson LLP. The… + read more

Attorney:

Noted Dallas appellate attorney, mediator and arbitrator Deborah Hankinson has been selected to the 2014-2015 listing of the Lawdragon 500 Leading Lawyers in America.

This is the third Lawdragon 500 selection for Ms. Hankinson, the founder of the Dallas appellate law boutique Hankinson LLP. The Leading Lawyers in America guide recognizes no more than one-tenth of 1 percent of the nation’s lawyers, making it one of the most elite recognitions in the legal profession.

The Lawdragon 500 recognition is the latest honor for the respected former Justice of the Supreme Court of Texas and the Fifth District Court of Appeals in Dallas. Most recently, Ms. Hankinson was recognized as a “Texas Trial Legend” by the Dallas Bar Association.

She previously has earned recognition from The Best Lawyers in America, Chambers USA, Martindale-Hubbell, Texas Super Lawyers, D Magazine, Benchmark Appellate, Texas Lawyer and the Dallas Business Journal.

She also has been honored by numerous professional organizations, including the Women’s Advocacy Project, Legal Aid of NorthWest Texas, the Texas Equal Access to Justice Foundation, the Southern Methodist University Dedman School of Law, the State Bar of Texas and the American Board of Trial Advocates.

Ms. Hankinson is Board Certified in Civil Appellate Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization and is a fellow in the American Academy of Appellate Lawyers. She serves on the Board of Directors and the Executive Committee for the American Arbitration Association.

The 2014-2015 Lawdragon 500 Leading Lawyers in America magazine will be published this summer and distributed to corporate counsel, private practitioners, academics and other leaders in the legal industry. The full Lawdragon 500 list can be found at www.Lawdragon.com.

Attorney:

 

Deborah Hankinson Recognized in Chambers USA for Ninth Consecutive Year

For the ninth consecutive year, Dallas attorney and mediator Deborah Hankinson has been recognized for her work in appellate law in Chambers USA, the respected guide to the nation’s top lawyers and law firms. With more than 25 years of experience and 150 full-time researchers… + read more

Attorney:

For the ninth consecutive year, Dallas attorney and mediator Deborah Hankinson has been recognized for her work in appellate law in Chambers USA, the respected guide to the nation’s top lawyers and law firms.

With more than 25 years of experience and 150 full-time researchers and editors, Chambers USA publisher Chambers and Partners is respected worldwide for its thorough guides to the legal profession. Chambers bases its rankings on thousands of phone interviews with attorneys and clients who identify those lawyers and law firms that demonstrate the top technical legal ability, professional conduct, client service, diligence, commitment and other qualities most valued by clients.

Attorney:

 

Deborah Hankinson and Rick Thompson Named Among Best Lawyers in Dallas by D Magazine

Rick Thompson and Deborah Hankinson again have been named to D Magazine’s annual list of the Best Lawyers in Dallas.  This is Ms. Hankinson’s tenth year to be included on the prestigious list and Mr. Thompson’s second year to be named. Hankinson LLP is one… + read more

Rick Thompson and Deborah Hankinson again have been named to D Magazine’s annual list of the Best Lawyers in Dallas.  This is Ms. Hankinson’s tenth year to be included on the prestigious list and Mr. Thompson’s second year to be named.

Hankinson LLP is one of only two firms with multiple attorneys selected to the exclusive listing based on their appellate work.

To assemble the list of the city’s top lawyers, D Magazine sought nominations from lawyers across the North Texas area.  A blue-ribbon panel of lawyers helped the magazine’s editors determine the final list of attorneys, which appears in the May 2015 issue of D Magazine.

 

 

Deborah Hankinson Teaches at Fordham University Conference

Deborah Hankinson spoke about alternative dispute resolution and its impact on trade and access to justice at a conference jointly presented by Fordham University School of Law and the American Arbitration Association entitled “Society, Commerce and Dispute Resolution: Goals for Justice and Trade.” Attorney: Deborah… + read more

Attorney:

Deborah Hankinson spoke about alternative dispute resolution and its impact on trade and access to justice at a conference jointly presented by Fordham University School of Law and the American Arbitration Association entitled “Society, Commerce and Dispute Resolution: Goals for Justice and Trade.”

Attorney:

 

Deborah Hankinson Elected to the American Arbitration Association’s Executive Committee

At the May 2015 meeting of the American Arbitration Association’s Board of Directors, Deborah Hankinson was elected to the organization’s elite Executive Committee.  The Executive Committee members address Association initiatives, strategy, policy matters, finances, legal developments impacting alternative dispute resolution, and other matters related to… + read more

At the May 2015 meeting of the American Arbitration Association’s Board of Directors, Deborah Hankinson was elected to the organization’s elite Executive Committee.  The Executive Committee members address Association initiatives, strategy, policy matters, finances, legal developments impacting alternative dispute resolution, and other matters related to the work of the Association.  The Executive Committee also is delegated broad authority to act on behalf of the Association’s board.

 

Deborah Hankinson Presents at American Arbitration Association Webinar

Deborah Hankinson, who frequently serves as an arbitrator and mediator, spoke at an educational webinar presented by the American Arbitration Association entitled “Developing the AAA Judicial Panel, Working Together.”  The focus of the webinar was the benefit of a judicial presence on arbitration panels. Attorney:… + read more

Deborah Hankinson, who frequently serves as an arbitrator and mediator, spoke at an educational webinar presented by the American Arbitration Association entitled “Developing the AAA Judicial Panel, Working Together.”  The focus of the webinar was the benefit of a judicial presence on arbitration panels.

 

Deborah Hankinson Among Dallas Bar Association’s Texas Trial Legends

Hankinson LLP founder and respected appellate attorney Deborah Hankinson was one of four attorneys honored April 8 by the Dallas Bar Association as a “Texas Trial Legend.” Her selection was based on her unique accomplishments as an attorney and jurist. Ms. Hankinson was a successful… + read more

Attorney:

Hankinson LLP founder and respected appellate attorney Deborah Hankinson was one of four attorneys honored April 8 by the Dallas Bar Association as a “Texas Trial Legend.” Her selection was based on her unique accomplishments as an attorney and jurist. Ms. Hankinson was a successful appellate attorney when she was selected to serve as a Justice on the Fifth District Court of Appeals in Dallas in 1995. In 1997 she was appointed to the Supreme Court of Texas. Since returning to private practice in 2002, she has expanded her role as one of the state’s top appellate attorneys, oral advocates, strategists, mediators, arbitrators and legal problem-solvers. Also honored at the Belo Mansion ceremony were C.L. Mike Schmidt, Bob Vial and the late W. Richard Bernays.

Attorney:

 

Order Granting New Trial Reviewed and Vacated on Mandamus

Brett Kutnick led a team of Hankinson lawyers, including Deborah Hankinson, Joseph Morris, Jennifer Rangel Stagen, and Stephanie Nelson, in successfully representing the defendants in a petition for writ of mandamus seeking to set aside a trial court’s order granting the plaintiffs a new trial… + read more

Brett Kutnick led a team of Hankinson lawyers, including Deborah Hankinson, Joseph Morris, Jennifer Rangel Stagen, and Stephanie Nelson, in successfully representing the defendants in a petition for writ of mandamus seeking to set aside a trial court’s order granting the plaintiffs a new trial after a multi-week jury trial concerning the alleged breach of an attorney-client contingency fee agreement. Following briefing, the Court of Appeals for the Fourth District of Texas in San Antonio conditionally granted the mandamus petition and ordered the trial court to vacate its order granting a new trial and issue a new order specifying its reasons for granting a new trial. In re Davenport, No. 04-14-00666-CV, 2015 WL 1089679 (Tex. App.—San Antonio Mar. 11, 2015, orig. proceeding) (mem. op.).

 

Deborah Hankinson Teaches at Oil & Gas Disputes Course

Deborah Hankinson presented “Do You Want to Arbitrate? Managing the Process When You Do” at the Oil & Gas Disputes Course (Negotiation, Arbitration and Litigation) sponsored by the State Bar of Texas and Texas Tech University School of Law on January 9, 2015, in Houston,… + read more

Deborah Hankinson presented “Do You Want to Arbitrate? Managing the Process When You Do” at the Oil & Gas Disputes Course (Negotiation, Arbitration and Litigation) sponsored by the State Bar of Texas and Texas Tech University School of Law on January 9, 2015, in Houston, Texas.

 

Deborah Hankinson Serves as Faculty Member for the 2014 College for New Judges in Austin, Texas

On December 10, 2014, Deborah Hankinson spoke on “Proper Role: Opinions & Oral Argument” during the College for New Judges in Austin, Texas. + read more

On December 10, 2014, Deborah Hankinson spoke on “Proper Role: Opinions & Oral Argument” during the College for New Judges in Austin, Texas. The College provides information and training for newly elected and appointed Judges in Texas.

 

Deborah Hankinson Spoke at the State Bar’s 32nd Annual Advanced Oil, Gas and Energy Resources Law Course on October 3, 2014

Deborah presented “The Arbitrator’s Perspective: Oil and Gas Arbitration.” + read more

Deborah presented “The Arbitrator’s Perspective: Oil and Gas Arbitration.”

 

Deborah Hankinson and Rick Thompson Named 2014 Texas Super Lawyers

Hankinson LLP attorneys Deborah Hankinson and Rick Thompson were named among the state’s top attorneys for 2014 by the publisher Texas Super Lawyers. Their inclusion was based on nominations from peers, an analysis of each attorney’s work, and a panel review. No more than 5%… + read more

Hankinson LLP attorneys Deborah Hankinson and Rick Thompson were named among the state’s top attorneys for 2014 by the publisher Texas Super Lawyers. Their inclusion was based on nominations from peers, an analysis of each attorney’s work, and a panel review. No more than 5% of all Texas lawyers are included in the annual listing. Deborah was singled out as one of the Top 10 and Top 100 attorneys in Texas, the Top 50 Women lawyers in Texas, and the Top 100 attorneys in Dallas-Fort Worth.

Page 1 of 41234